The internet has a curious talent for resurrecting the most unlikely of cinematic relics, and this month’s viral target was none other than Little Nicky. Out of nowhere, a slick “official” poster for Little Nicky 2 set timelines aflame, promising a 2025 Netflix release and the return of Adam Sandler’s most awkward spawn-of-Satan persona. The image spread like wildfire, sparking equal parts nostalgia and disbelief. But there’s one tiny, pitchfork-shaped catch—none of it is real.
In the age of AI-generated art and hyperactive fan speculation, the line between rumor and reality can be razor-thin. For a few glorious days, people were ready to believe Sandler would once again don the puffy jacket, mumble through his overbite, and navigate Hell’s absurdities. Yet reputable outlets like The Direct and Snopes quickly poured holy water on the flames, confirming what some suspected: this was a fan-made hoax with no official ties to Sandler or Netflix.
The truth is, Little Nicky wasn’t exactly a hit when it first emerged from the underworld in 2000. Backed by a hefty $80 million budget, it managed just $58.3 million globally—a commercial shortfall that sent it straight to the DVD shelves. Critics largely roasted it, but the film’s unapologetically weird humor—blending slapstick, surrealism, and heavy doses of metalhead energy—helped it gain a strange afterlife among a devoted cult following.
That following has kept the fires of Hell smoldering over the years, quoting lines, sharing memes, and half-jokingly campaigning for a sequel that would drag Nicky back into the spotlight. For them, the viral poster wasn’t just a prank—it was a glimpse of a parallel universe where Hollywood takes bigger risks on its oddest properties.
But Adam Sandler, ever the pragmatic showman, has shown no signs of wanting to revisit Nicky’s red-hot turf. His comedic energies are currently aimed elsewhere, most notably toward the officially confirmed Happy Gilmore 2, which carries a much safer box-office pedigree. Given Sandler’s current trajectory, returning to Little Nicky would be a nostalgia gamble in an industry increasingly driven by guaranteed returns.
There’s also the question of tone. Little Nicky’s humor was very much a product of its era—broad, unapologetically silly, and leaning into absurdities that might land differently today. A modern sequel would face the challenge of honoring the original’s manic energy while updating its comedic sensibilities for an audience raised on a different rhythm of jokes.
Still, the idea has undeniable charm. The original’s world-building—complete with Harvey Keitel as a weary Satan, Reese Witherspoon as Nicky’s angelic mom, and a supporting cast of Sandler’s comedy troupe—left plenty of room for more misadventures. If handled with the right mix of irreverence and affection, Little Nicky 2 could thrive as a self-aware return to Hell, poking fun at both its own legacy and the state of comedy today.
Unfortunately, the more realistic scenario is that Little Nicky 2 will remain a meme-fueled fever dream. Studios are cautious, and while streaming platforms like Netflix have revived cult properties before, the combination of a costly effects-heavy production and uncertain audience reach makes this particular resurrection unlikely.
That said, there’s no denying the buzz this fake poster generated. In a matter of days, it reminded the internet of the joy—however niche—that the original brought to those who embraced its ridiculousness. It also proved that even after 25 years, Nicky’s awkward charm hasn’t completely faded into the fiery ether.
For now, fans will have to keep their hopes—and their pitchforks—in check. Little Nicky 2 may not be on the horizon, but the original remains a devilishly odd comfort watch for those who appreciate comedy that plays by no earthly rules. And if Hollywood ever decides to crack open Hell’s gates for Nicky again, well… let’s just say the fanbase will be ready, brimstone in hand.
Until then, this rumor is best enjoyed like a fine piece of Satan’s candy—sweet, fleeting, and entirely unreal.
Watch movie:
*Content is hosted on a partner site.
